Primark and M&S announce responsible exit from Myanmar

Over the past month, two major UK brands have announced they plan to leave Myanmar because of mounting evidence that it is impossible to do the due diligence needed to protect workers under the new military regime.

 

On 12th September 2022, just over a year after the trade unions in Myanmar called on international brands to leave Myanmar because of the military coup, the Ethical Trading Initiative (ETI) released an independent report that they had commissioned to find out if the trade union’s calls were justified.

 

Described as an investigation into the ability of brands to do due diligence in conflict zones, using Myanmar as a case study, the upset that the trade unions call for brands to leave caused among civil society groups and brands meant an initiative such as ETI, that brings brands, civil society groups and some global trade union federations around a shared table, had to respond.

 

“We are waiting for the ETI report” has, for almost a year, been the stock response from all the major high street brands to questions about their future presence in Myanmar. When No Sweat and the Global Women’s Strike wrote to all the major brands about listening to the Burmese trade unions and planning a responsible exit, those that took the time to respond all said the same thing–they were worried about the impact on workers lives if we leave and we won’t take action until we get the ETI report.

 

There were fears among our Myanmar Military: Never in Fashion coalition and among trade unions in Myanmar that the ETI report would simply provide cover for brands to ignore the union’s reports of worsening conditions and poverty wages in the garment industry since the coup. In July No Sweat and Global Women’s Strike hosted exiled Burmese trade union leader Khaing Zar Aung and met with the head of the ETI to relay those fears.

 

In the end the report did support the trade unions reports on the deteriorating conditions since the coup, stating ‘the report provides credible evidence of forced labour and exploitation at a sector level, with evidence of workers facing long hours, low wages, unpaid overtime and harassment. In addition, workers are unable to exercise their right to freedom of association’. From the interviews that the report’s authors carried out, the overwhelming feeling by people on the ground is that since the coup there has been ‘a culture of fear pervades normal life and extends into the workplace.’

 

While the report didn’t outright recommend that brands leave, they did provide compelling evidence that staying would jeopardise their basic commitments to Corporate Social Responsibility. However, they also stated that leaving would throw tens of thousands into abject poverty, without offering any solutions to square the circle of fostering exploitation by staying or causing destitution by leaving.

 

This has given some brands (namely H&M, Adidas, Lidl, Next, Uniqlo and Zara) enough wiggle room to argue that they must stay in order to protect their garment workers and say they will do everything to ensure their code of conduct is followed in the factories they source from–thereby ignoring the trade unions and the majority of the report’s finding. Their arguments ring hollow, as Khaing Zar pointed out in a recent interview on The No Sweat Podcast with Andrew O’Neill. She highlighted the brands action during the pandemic of cancelling orders on mass that threw hundreds of thousands of Burmese garment workers into poverty, so ‘why now are they worried about job losses in the garment sector?’ she asks before coming to the conclusion, ‘they are lying.’

 

Now, both Primark and Marks and Spencer have joined Tesco and Aldi in announcing they will leave Myanmar due to the deteriorating situation. The term ‘responsible exit’ has been used by both but very little detail has been given as to what they might look like. We sincerely doubt that even they know what they mean by the term.

 

Broadly speaking, No Sweat welcomes the decision by all brands that are suspending orders in Myanmar, as the first rule of international solidarity is that you support the calls being made by the people on the ground and not dictate what decisions they should be making from afar. The trade unions are calling for a responsible exit and the brands should listen and work with the trade unions to make that happen.

 

If Primark and M&S are serious about a responsible exit they need to work in full cooperation with Burmese unions and provide financial support to the worker they are leaving behind. That means setting up a fund to provide workers with a basic income for at least the next year, or as long as necessary. This is not unaffordable for these billion-dollar corporations, the minimum wage in Myanmar is $2.50 a day. They must provide this as a basic income to the workers they are leaving behind, the workers that have made their product and helped create their wealth, but also they need to do more to support the fight for democracy in Myanmar.  

 

Marks & Spencer’s make the claim in their corporate social responsibility documents that their beliefs and values are aligned with a commitment to the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, it is likely Primark have similar statements in theirs. If such claims are genuine—if this is more than just words—then simply leaving Myanmar and abandoning its people to a brutal authoritarian regime is not good enough. These brands must make every effort to use their influence and economic power to support the movement to restore democracy and human rights in Myanmar.

Scroll to Top